The Most Valuable 1995 Hockey Cards

1995 NHL season began with a lockout, shortening the regular season from 82 games to just 48, with the playoffs also played under this compressed schedule. The New Jersey Devils swept the Detroit Red Wings to win the Stanley Cup. This year marked the twilight of Gretzky’s prime, the return of Lemieux, and the rise of young superstars like Jagr, Sakic, and Lindros.

Related

The 10 Most Valuable Hockey Cards

Legends on ice, treasures in hand.

The mid-90s were known for overproduction in sports trading cards, which affected long-term value, but demand at the time was strong. In response to growing market competition, card companies began producing higher-quality, shinier, and rarer cards. Now, let’s leave the time machine behind and explore today’s market value of these 1995 hockey cards!

10

Pavel Bure [Mirror Gold] #16 1995 Select Certified

Mirror Gold cards are among the rarest parallels in the Select Certified series, printed in extremely limited quantities with only a few found per box. By 1995, Pavel Bure was recognized as one of the NHL’s fastest and most electrifying players. Nicknamed “The Russian Rocket,” he was known for his incredible speed and explosive scoring ability, capable of changing the outcome of a game on his own.

The mid-1990s marked the peak of his career. In the 1993-94 season, he led the Vancouver Canucks to the Stanley Cup Finals and delivered an outstanding playoff performance, solidifying his status as one of the league’s biggest stars. His popularity also fueled high demand for his cards among fans and collectors.

9

Manon Rheaume 1995 Classic Autographs

This card’s value stems from Manon Rheaume’s unique and groundbreaking role in hockey history. It is more than just a sports card—it honors a trailblazer who broke gender barriers in the game. Rheaume made history in 1992 by signing with the NHL’s Tampa Bay Lightning and becoming the first and only woman to play in an NHL exhibition game.

She was also the first woman to compete in one of North America’s four major professional sports leagues. This unprecedented achievement makes the card highly significant and collectible. Its value is further enhanced by Rheaume’s autograph, making it sought after by both hockey card collectors and those who collect iconic moments in women’s sports history.

8

Jaromir Jagr [Mirror Gold] #38 1995 Select Certified

Mirror Gold cards from the 1995 Select Certified set are among the rarest parallel versions, but rarity alone isn’t what makes this card special. By 1995, Jaromir Jagr had become one of the NHL’s most dominant and productive players.

Related

The 10 Most Valuable Paul Coffey Hockey Cards

From the ice to your collection…

Already a two-time Stanley Cup champion with the Mario Lemieux-led Pittsburgh Penguins, Jagr reached the peak of his career during the 1995-96 season, recording 149 points—the second-highest in the league. He had won his first Art Ross Trophy in the 1994-95 season and set a career-high with 62 goals and 87 assists the following year. With 24 NHL seasons and the second-most points in league history after Wayne Gretzky, Jagr’s legacy makes this card highly desirable.

7

Patrick Roy [w/ Coating] #13 1995 Finest

The 1995 Topps Finest series featuring legendary goaltender Patrick Roy stood out for its advanced production quality, with cards coated in a special finish that gave them a shiny, durable, and premium appearance. Roy, known for breaking numerous records and achieving major milestones throughout his career, experienced a pivotal moment in 1995 when he was traded from the Montreal Canadiens to the Colorado Avalanche.

The high-profile trade became even more significant when he led his new team to a Stanley Cup victory. This card captures both the end of his Canadiens era and the beginning of his Avalanche legacy, giving it added historical value. It’s especially sought after by fans of both franchises.

6

Mario Lemieux [Refractor] #BB10 1995 Bowman’s Best

Refractor cards from the Bowman’s Best series are known for being rarer and more valuable than standard cards, featuring special reflective surfaces and appearing at low insertion rates. Mario Lemieux is considered one of the greatest hockey players of all time, having set numerous records, won two Stanley Cups, and inspired the sports world with his battle against Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

The period following 1995 marked one of his brightest comebacks. After missing the entire 1993-94 season due to Hodgkin’s lymphoma treatment and playing partially in the lockout-shortened 1994-95 season, Lemieux returned in 1995-96 with an incredible performance—scoring 69 goals and recording 92 assists for a total of 161 points. That season, he earned both the Art Ross and Hart Trophies.

5

Wayne Gretzky #375 1995 Topps Marquee Men Power Boosters

Topps’ special Power Boosters parallel series is rarer than base cards and features a reflective surface that catches the light. In the mid-1990s, these shiny designs were considered innovative, and when combined with legendary players like Wayne Gretzky, they generated significant interest among collectors. The limited production and low pull rates added to their value.

Related

10 Best Sports Games For Beginners

Sports games are exciting to play, whether you’re experienced or new. If you’re a rookie, here are the best to check out.

In 1995, Gretzky was nearing the later stages of his career but remained one of the NHL’s elite players. He was the captain of the Los Angeles Kings and was still widely recognized for his exceptional passing and playmaking abilities. This card represents a key chapter in his time with the Kings.

4

Wayne Gretzky [Refractor w/ Coating] #180 1995 Finest

The hockey legend’s record-breaking achievements firmly place him among the most dominant athletes in sports history. Known as “The Great One,” any card featuring Wayne Gretzky—especially a parallel version—is unsurprisingly valuable to collectors. Refractor cards, with their holographic, light-reflective surface, add an extra layer of appeal.

The coating not only enhances the card’s shine but also protects it from long-term wear. The 1995 season marked one of Gretzky’s final full years before being traded to the St. Louis Blues during the 1995-96 season. In the lockout-shortened 1994-95 season, he tallied 48 points in 48 games with the Kings. This card reflects that era in his iconic career.

3

Wayne Gretzky [Refractor] #180 1995 Finest

This card is the Refractor version of the #180 Wayne Gretzky 1995 Finest card. While all 1995 Finest cards originally came with a protective coating, collectors often debated peeling it off, as the underlying Refractor surface was particularly striking.

Ultimately, rare and visually striking versions like Refractors tend to attract strong demand. In 1995, Gretzky was nearing the end of his career but remained a significant figure. After joining the Los Angeles Kings from the Edmonton Oilers in 1988, he was still the team’s most recognizable player in 1995.

2

Mario Lemieux [Mirror Gold] #1 1995 Select Certified

One of the most striking aspects of this card featuring Mario Lemieux, one of hockey’s most legendary and unique figures, is that it’s a Mirror Gold from the 1995 Select Certified series. These rare parallels were inserted approximately one in every five packs, making them limited and highly collectible.

Lemieux’s battle with Hodgkin lymphoma in 1993—and his remarkable return to win the scoring title that same season despite undergoing radiation treatment—stands as an unmatched achievement in sports history. After missing the entire 1993-94 season due to Hodgkin’s lymphoma treatment and playing partially in the lockout-shortened 1994-95 season, he returned in dominant form in 1995-96. This card captures the moment just after that incredible comeback.

1

Wayne Gretzky [Mirror Gold] #23 1995 Select Certified

The 1995 Select Certified series was significant for its time, as it was released as a super premium card set. Mirror Gold cards are among the rarest and most visually striking parallels in this set. Unlike the standard cards with silver finishes, these feature a shiny gold background.

The 1995 Select Certified cards were also produced with high-end features like 24-point metallic card stock and dual lamination, which enhanced both durability and visual appeal. Gretzky’s cards have always been in demand due to his long-standing fan base and importance to hockey card collectors. Rare and eye-catching parallels like Mirror Gold further boost their value.

Next

The 10 Most Valuable 1989 Hockey Cards

Chill out with the best ’89 hockey cards!