Assassin’s Creed Shadows and Rise of the Ronin are two major open-world action games set in historical Japan, offering widely distinct experiences. Ubisoft’s Shadows transports players to 16th-century Japan with dual protagonists, blending stealth and action. Team Ninja’s Ronin immerses players in the Bakumatsu era, emphasizing player choice and dynamic combat.
Related
8 Movies And TV Shows To Watch If You Like Assassin’s Creed Shadows
These movies and TV shows have the essence of Japanese storytelling.
While both games explore Japan’s rich history, they cater to different playstyles and narratives. This comparison breaks down key aspects to determine which title stands out in various categories, so you know which one to pick in your next excursion through feudal Japan.
8
Supporting Cast – Rise Of The Ronin
Romance Included
One of Rise of the Ronin’s standout features is its approach to the supporting cast. As you explore the Bakumatsu-era world, you form bonds with a wide variety of characters — from historical figures like Ryoma Sakamoto to faction leaders and local allies. These relationships are shaped through dialogue choices, side quests, and moral decisions, offering narrative weight and even gameplay benefits like support in combat or story divergence.
The system feels reminiscent of companion mechanics in deeper RPGs, encouraging players to invest emotionally and strategically in the people around them. By contrast, Assassin’s Creed Shadows focuses more on its two main protagonists, with side characters often playing secondary roles. While still engaging, they don’t offer the same level of interactive depth. For players who value a cast that evolves with them and reflects their choices, Rise of the Ronin delivers a more immersive and rewarding supporting ensemble.
7
Main Characters – Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Compelling Dual Protagonists
Where Shadows lacks customization, it makes up for it with character depth. It features two main protagonists: Yasuke, the historical samurai, and Naoe, a fictional shinobi. Their contrasting backgrounds, abilities, and personal quests provide rich narrative variety. Yasuke brings strength and a code of honor, while Naoe emphasizes agility and vengeance, offering two lenses through which to explore 16th-century Japan.
Rise of the Ronin tells a more personalized story, but its protagonist is ultimately a blank slate. While this allows player expression, it comes at the cost of narrative specificity. If you’re looking for a story shaped by strong, well-defined characters, Assassin’s Creed Shadows has the edge.
6
Story – Rise Of The Ronin
Delivering A More Engaging Narrative
Rise of the Ronin stands out for its mature, branching storyline set during the tumultuous Bakumatsu period — the fall of the Tokugawa Shogunate. The game allows you to align with various factions, make moral choices, and see different outcomes based on your decisions. The political backdrop, coupled with deeply personal stakes, gives the story weight and replay value.
Related
6 Best Easter Eggs And Hidden Details In Rise Of The Ronin
Did you spot all these hidden details and references in Rise of the Ronin?
Assassin’s Creed Shadows offers a linear but well-crafted story centered on resistance against feudal corruption. While the writing is strong and the dual perspectives add dimension, it doesn’t offer the same narrative flexibility. In terms of story depth and player impact, Ronin is the more immersive and choice-driven experience.
5
Stealth Mechanics – Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Excelling In Stealth Gameplay
Stealth has always been a pillar of the Assassin’s Creed franchise, and Shadows refines the formula with modern enhancements. Naoe’s sections offer tools like grappling hooks, cover mechanics, and different visibility systems. Players can scale walls, distract guards, and plan infiltrations with a range of gadgets and techniques that make every stealth encounter feel layered and satisfying.
Rise of the Ronin includes basic stealth elements — such as crouching and silent takedowns — but stealth is not its focus. Most encounters encourage open combat rather than infiltration. For players who love tactical, slow-burn gameplay and quiet eliminations, Assassin’s Creed Shadows provides a deeper stealth experience.
4
Combat – Rise Of The Ronin
Dynamic Combat Systems
When it comes to combat, Rise of the Ronin clearly benefits from Team Ninja’s pedigree. The game offers a fast, fluid system with multiple fighting styles, weapon categories, and parry mechanics. Players can switch stances mid-fight, adapt to enemy types, and chain together complex combos in a way that feels both responsive and rewarding.
Assassin’s Creed Shadows retains the methodical, weighty combat of recent AC entries, with noticeable differences between Yasuke’s brute strength and Naoe’s speed. While enjoyable, it lacks the same finesse and learning curve. If satisfying melee combat is a priority, Ronin delivers a more refined and challenging system.
3
Visuals – Assassin’s Creed Shadows
Superior Visual Fidelity
Assassin’s Creed Shadows is arguably Ubisoft’s most visually striking game to date. Built on the latest version of the Anvil engine, it features dynamic lighting, weather systems, and richly detailed environments that bring feudal Japan to life. From snowy mountain shrines to bustling villages, every location is dripping with atmosphere and authenticity.
Related
Assassin’s Creed Shadows: Best Engravings For Your Equipment
Make sure to use these equipment engravings in AC Shadows.
Rise of the Ronin also captures its historical period well, but its visuals lean more stylized and less detailed in comparison. Texture work and lighting are solid but not on par with the photorealism seen in Shadows. If visual immersion is a major factor for you, Assassin’s Creed Shadows holds the edge.
2
Setting – Rise Of The Ronin
Immersive Historical Setting
While both games are set in Japan, they explore very different eras. Rise of the Ronin takes place in the 19th century during Japan’s transition from isolation to modernization. This era of social upheaval and foreign intervention creates a unique tension that deeply informs the gameplay and worldbuilding. Players interact with real historical figures and make choices that shape the nation’s fate.
Assassin’s Creed Shadows is set earlier, during the Sengoku period. Though it’s richly detailed, it leans more heavily into fictionalization. For players seeking historical nuance and political complexity, Rise of the Ronin is the more grounded and culturally rich experience.
1
Winner – Rise Of The Ronin
A Proper Look At Japan
Both Assassin’s Creed Shadows and Rise of the Ronin offer compelling visions of Japan through different lenses. Shadows wins in terms of stealth gameplay, visual presentation, and strong protagonists. However, Rise of the Ronin offers a deeper RPG experience with superior customization, branching narratives, dynamic combat, and a richly immersive historical setting.
While fans of the Assassin’s Creed series will find much to enjoy in Shadows, Rise of the Ronin provides a more flexible and player-driven adventure — one that invites multiple playthroughs and reflects your choices. For those seeking both challenge and depth, Rise of the Ronin is the better game overall.
Next
Is Rise Of The Ronin Worth It?
A Shogunate era souls-like, but is it worth the price tag?
